By Christopher Mann
Last Thursday Congressman Mike Pence (IN-6) addressed a town
hall meeting of about 100 constituents who braved a fresh six-inch blanket of
snow in the northeastern town of Bluffton, about
30 minutes south of Fort Wayne.
Though the winter storm delayed the meeting by almost a half-hour, that didn’t
seem to dampen the Congressman’s reception, who enjoyed rousing applause on
positions mostly related to health care reform and Afghanistan. The meeting was taped
by CSPAN and will reportedly this next week.
The following are some highlights:
Health Care Reform: “The cure is worse than the disease.”
Not surprisingly, Pence’s first snowball-salvo was against
the health care reform bill passed by the Senate last week and now cryptically
being reconciled to the House version by House Democrats, Senate Democrats and
the White House (pro-life democrats in the House have reportedly been uninvited
to these negotiations.)
“[Health care reform] legislation is moving forward behind
closed doors as we speak today. I believe we should scrap the current health
care bill,” the four-term congressman told the mostly senior-citizen crowd.
“Congress must reform health care,” he said, but this bill
will hurt health care, not help it, arguing that health care reform should
include allowing consumers to purchase health care insurance across state
lines, which would increase competition and lower costs. Pence, who chairs the
House Republican Conference, said Congress must also reform runaway medical
malpractice litigation. He repeatedly referred attendants to the GOP’s plan for
health care reform, hosted at GOP.gov.
Rick: Loved his brother to debt
“Rick,” a Bluffton resident, charged Pence and the GOP of
double speak when they favor big government programs while they’re in power but
oppose them when the Democrats rule. He accused Pence and the GOP of playing
politics with important legislation, and referenced his own painful story of incurring
a six-figure debt when helping his incapacitated brother survive an illness.
Pence conceded that his party left their conservative
moorings and approved government growth like the 2003 Medicare Prescription
Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act (MMA). The bill was originally
estimated around $400 billion over ten years, but later revised in 2005—after
the election—to $1.2 trillion, comparable to the cost of the current health
care reform legislation. Pence was among a minority of conservatives who voted
against the legislation, and has noted that the GOP’s poor showing in the 2008
elections amounted to a sound rebuke to a party that has talked conservative
fiscal management but walked something else in recent years.
Pence disagreed that objecting to a government takeover of
health care is the equivalent of playing politics with important reform, saying
that it is possible to lower health care insurance costs, but the key is to
increase competition, not protect turf, as state borders do now.
Afghanistan:
Why tell the enemy when you plan to give up?
“Monty” noted that following a recent trip to Afghanistan,
Congressman Mark Souder recently announced his changed view, believing that President
Obama’s 30,000 soldier surge—modeled after President Bush’s Iraqi surge of
2007—can work. Pence said that he also recently visited Afghanistan and after
meeting with General Stanley McChrystal, Afghanistan’s president Hamid Karzai,
and other U.S. commanders and Afghan political leaders, he left the fledgling
democracy with a similar conclusion that the U.S. can win the war, but with one
large reservation: “I don’t think it ever makes sense to tell the enemy when
you’re going to stop fighting,” Pence told the Bluffton crowd to a rousing
applause.
“[General McChrystal] told me that they have the resources
and personnel and they can get the job done if
they have the time to do it,” Pence said. He warned, however, that leaders
on the ground told him, “Look, the Taliban has been using that July 2011
[withdrawal] deadline as a recruiting tool. They’re walking up to people and
saying, ‘see, they (the Americans) are leaving. We are staying.’
The U.S. Forces want to come home, and Congress wants them
to come home, but he says that he can’t figure out why the President insists on
signaling to the Taliban via a published deadline how long they have to hold
out.
He says that we must have a credible government in Afghanistan and he recently co-signed a letter containing a “deafening” message to
President Karzai to that effect, noting that the upcoming parliamentary
elections must be run with much more transparency and integrity than the
presidential elections of 2009, largely dismissed as fraudulent by the global
community.
Pence and his colleagues have called on President Karzai to
delay the parliamentary elections, pass major election reform law, and then
reschedule the elections to increase the world’s confidence of a representative
government. Pence says that the President has not yet agreed to this, but that
the U.S. Congress would continue to press for such reform.
Christopher Mann is
a public relations consultant in Fort
Wayne. Email Chris at chris@christophermann.com or Twitter: @MannCub.
Recent Comments